BEYONCE TO TESTIFY IN SONGWRITING SUIT
![]()
THE FACTS
A songwriter has sued Beyonce claiming she stole lyrics for the Destiny’s Child single, “Cater 2 U.”
THE SPIN
In 2006 a man claimed Beyonce copy and pasted his lyrics for the man-serving anthem, “Cater 2 U.”
And now that a judge has allowed the case to be heard before a jury, the Queen Bey herself will take the witness stand next month in Chicago.
Chicago songwriter and performer Rickey Allen says it’s his song, and he copyrighted the song – also entitled “Cater 2 U” – back in the mid 1990s. He says he’s performed the song for years and has updated the copyright multiple times, most recently in the 2000.
Via the Chicago Sun-Times:
When Allen’s song says: “I want to rub you down,” Destiny’s Child asks: “Want a foot rub?”Is this another frivolous suit or are those lyrics too close for comfort?
Allen’s lyrics say: “The tub has hot steam rising,” and “I’m waiting to soak your body through.”
The Destiny’s Child song offers to: “Let me run your bath water.”
“Do we say [Beyonce's] responsible for copying? Yes. But there’s no such thing as innocent copying, even if it’s unintentional,” said Allen’s lawyer, Matt Wildermuth. “The jury will decide the notion that these are simple coincidences.”
Allen says he passed a copy of his “Cater 2 U” to Chicago remixer Maurice Joshua, and the two planned to collaborate on a demo.
That never happened, Allen says. But Joshua later spent several hours in a session with Destiny’s Child recording a different song, according to court papers. Joshua says he never had a copy of Allen’s work.
Early Monday morning, Beyonce’s band mate, Michelle Williams got her digs in, tweeting:
Good Morning!!!! Hmmmm….you know you’ve made it when you’re sued every year! Work hard and get your own coins!
Source
YOUR SPIN: What do you think? Is it a coincidence? Tell us here.
Image courtesy of theinsider.com
(*The views contained herein are solely the views of their respective authors, and do not express the views of TV One. TV One does not take responsibility for their content.)




